• jet@hackertalks.com
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    I’m just trying to be logical. There is a statement here which I believe I’ve demonstrated as blatantly false. Calling that as false is a good thing to do, and I believe every critical thinker should acknowledge false statements when they have the evidence.

    My point in this thread, is it is immaterial if Israel wanted to help or not, that had no physical impact on hamasa’s releasing of prisoners.

    Both belligerence in this conflict have demonstrable lies. There’s no good side here.

    Yes in the last several days more prisoners have been released. That’s a good thing. It demonstrates Hamas is trying to negotiate. Or at least start negotiations. Good. Less people need to die. Though I believe the right play for Israeli military was to move in within the first few days, and occupy the city, and put a new leadership in place. The fact that they’ve waited two weeks is removing their global mandate. They’ve waited too long. Indications seem to be that their current strategy is to push the population as far south as possible, prevent them from moving north again. Turn the north part of the Gaza strip into a DMZ, with no Palestinians living there. Basically increase the pressure, I don’t think that’s a long-term viable strategy, but it appears to be what they’re setting up.

    But that’s the wider conflict, I will respond to every comment on this thread saying my logic is wrong, I like logic I will defend logic, and I will acknowledge my logic is incorrect when prevented with evidence to the contrary. And the evidence has to be within the self-presented statements of this one Hamas statement. Calling out a lie, for a lie, when all the evidence needed to demonstrate it’s a lie is in its own statement, is something I believe very strongly in. It has nothing to do with the overall political climate.

    • ???@lemmy.worldOP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      1 year ago

      Israel going into Gaza would have meant a much bigger genocide than the one we see today…