it consequently raises the cost of borrowing on someone who paid back the full loan plus interest
This is mostly likely untrue because she was paying off her debt the whole time she had the loan, and her credit score and history were probably improving that whole time. Maybe her score went up 300 points over the years of that loan, and then dropped 35 points.
her credit score and history were probably improving that whole time
Until she paid it off, at which point it dropped.
Maybe her score went up 300 points over the years of that loan
Maybe, but I highly doubt it. And 35 points is a big drop when you’re already in the 700-range. That can be worth a quarter point on a mortgage loan, which will end up costing you tens of thousands of dollars over the life of the note.
And 35 points is a big drop when you’re already in the 700-range.
Which means the tons of points she likely gained by paying off the debt for years saved her at least a point.
I’m not arguing that a lower credit score isn’t worse, I’m pointing out that cherry picking a single month movement to claim that she got screwed for doing something that actually likely helped her doesn’t make any sense.
This is mostly likely untrue because she was paying off her debt the whole time she had the loan, and her credit score and history were probably improving that whole time. Maybe her score went up 300 points over the years of that loan, and then dropped 35 points.
Until she paid it off, at which point it dropped.
Maybe, but I highly doubt it. And 35 points is a big drop when you’re already in the 700-range. That can be worth a quarter point on a mortgage loan, which will end up costing you tens of thousands of dollars over the life of the note.
Which means the tons of points she likely gained by paying off the debt for years saved her at least a point.
I’m not arguing that a lower credit score isn’t worse, I’m pointing out that cherry picking a single month movement to claim that she got screwed for doing something that actually likely helped her doesn’t make any sense.