Wait! Those torrent clients are written with programming languages! We should sue the people who made the programming languages for encouraging piracy!
And pirates are using hardware to commit their dirty deeds!
Maybe this is how technological society crumbles, one lawsuit at a time.
That’s funny that you mention hardware, cause in Germany you pay a set fee for each device (13.19€ for a computer, 6.25€ for a phone) on purchase since it could be used to create copies of media.
I’m just getting my money’s worth, officer.
In Denmark it is lawful copies of a media. Problem is that almost all media is copyright protected and it is illegal to circumvent that. So essentially it is a free tax for the organization that represents the artists without any checks and balances to make sure those money actually get distributed to the artists afterwards.
Which fee are you referring to? Never heard of that
Danke!
If I can prove that I downloaded a torrent of an AppleTV show on my Mac, will Apple sue itself?
Meanwhile the writers of assembly - the root of all programming languages - are shaking in their boots.
So parents can sue gun companies right?
And they can sue the state for giving out driver’s license
It’s just a tool…for killing, very efficient killing tool
True, and a knife is an effective tool for cutting, the problem comes in when one decides instead of shooting some paper or cutting a steak, they shoot or cut a person (excluding legal self defense ofc, that’s fine).
No, that’s different. People kill people, not guns.
/s
It’s true though. When was the last time a person ever killed a gun?
/joke
Torrent clients don’t download torrents, people download torrents. See? No difference.
Actually, torrent clients download files, not torrents.
Point, set, match!
And sue politicians on the take
They should sue movie producers. After all, they regularly supply the pirates with fresh wares.
Someone doesn’t understand peer2peer filesharing. Next they will sue Microsoft for allowing pirated thing to run…
It’s pretty easy: there’s no culpability on either side. It’s not either-or. If guns and ammo and knife manufacturers are not responsible for murder than neither are ISPs and software developers responsible for piracy.
If the courts don’t like that an IP isn’t a person, then they can pressure congress to change the laws. Until then, everyone can go fuck off
With that logic they should sue the creators of the AV1 codec as well. Lots of pirated movies will be encoded with it…
They should sue Alan Turing and John von Neumann.
plenty of legal uses of the protocol. whats different here?
e.
Grande doesn’t explain why or when developers of torrent clients should be held liable for piracy. Popular torrent clients and sites that distribute this software are typically content-neutral and don’t actively encourage piracy. That is similar to the defense Grande relies on.
just graspin at straws it seems
In a way, they’re making a point. Just because they provide internet shouldn’t mean that they are the ones that should pay damages to record companies. But neither should torrent client developers. If you can’t catch the end user, then that’s your problem. If you’re that concerned, make your material more accessibile.
Plenty of legal uses. For example, it was legitimately faster for me to install deluge and torrent Ubuntu than it was to just download Ubuntu.
There’s so many other legitimate uses, but that’s the main one I used it for
Same with large academic datasets. You can’t rely on most academics to maintain their work past publication, nor to have machines capable of serving that much data in one go.
Well if that argument works out for the studios, Oneida better get ready because I’ll be seeing them in court. After all, they made the spoons that I used to eat the ice cream that made me fat.
The same people that would use the “they made the software that was used for infringement” will be the ones stating that “the manufacturer of this firearm is not responsible for it being used in this mass-shooting”.
Kinda funny how the main driving point behind their argument is “does this affect me and my bottom line”
It’s not a serious suggestion, they’re just using this as a “fuck off” response to the record labels.
“One two three not it.”
You can sue anyone for anything - doesn’t mean you’re going to win.
lol good luck tracking down someone who releases software into the wild.
Brb downloading the piratebay on the piratebay
Completely insane.
Sie the stupid animal that crawled out of the water so we evolved into humans, who can pirate digital goods.
Those silly old suits. The world left them behind long ago.
Why is it always that a torrentfreak link is posted here and it’s something negative and fear mongering?
Because part of their job is sharing all the batshit people argue in court that affects the space?
Whose job? And why does inconsequential rubbish that will be laughed at need to be reported?
Torrent Freak’s.
They cover news in the torrent and piracy space. This is very clearly news. It’s literally the whole purpose of the site.