I don’t think that any single score is going to make everyone happy.

Maybe if there are multiple user-scoring systems run by various sources, and I can choose which score I want to use as a metric.

Like, I think that the Marxist-Leninist crowd on some of the left-wing instances is bonkers, but I imagine that they’d say the same thing about me or other people who subscribe to mainstream economics in general. You’re not going to find a Single Source of Truth on that matter.