🏳️‍⚧️ trans girl [she/her] 🏳️‍⚧️

New account, same Emma!!

old accounts: Emma@kglitch.social & emma@kbin.sh

Let’s hope this instance doesn’t go extinct like the others!

  • 3 Posts
  • 24 Comments
Joined 10 months ago
cake
Cake day: January 14th, 2024

help-circle









  • -Emma-@fedia.iotoLGBTQ+@beehaw.orgAlly in training...
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    edit-2
    7 months ago

    I get the suspicion that some of the more spirited discussions so far came with a tinge of suspicion that I’m one of the bad folks looking to invade spaces and sow discord,

    Yeah, we generally have to have our guard up, especially in these types of threads. I don’t know if you’re familiar with the “just asking questions” type of transphobe, but it is a very real problem for communities like this one. The topic or phrasing of a question can raise red-flags for sure.

    But I believe that you’re being sincere.


  • -Emma-@fedia.iotoLGBTQ+@beehaw.orgAlly in training...
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    edit-2
    7 months ago

    For some of us yes, and for others no.

    It’s difficult for me to even imagine the complexities of such a world that lacks gender norms. Would there be fewer trans people? Possibly. But in such a world, there would still be trans people like me that feel a strong need for surgery.

    Edit: Forgot to mention HRT, which many of us would still need.






  • I browsed the communities on their instance using mlmym so I could see the full list. Then I tried to access the lemmytoday community from my Mbin account, and I got a 404 error.

    So that’s what I meant when I said I can’t report things to the admins on lemmy.today, since I can’t post on their dedicated community.

    I’ve noticed recently that my instance can’t fetch new communities anymore. For instance, I fetched all of the good LGBTQ+ accounts months ago without an account, and they all eventually federated across. But I can’t fetch asktransgender@lemmy.blahaj.zone or any other communities that aren’t already federated. I was thankfully able to fetch trans@lemmy.blahaj.zone before this issue.

    On another note, if moderator actions don’t federate across instances, does that mean when I see this:

    [Thread, post or comment was deleted by the moderator]

    the comment was deleted by a moderator on my Mbin instance, rather than a moderator on Blahaj? In that case, I would think my reports are working.




  • The eviltoast.org instance doesn’t seem to have much local content, and a recent post asks:

    Why has Lemmy.ml and feddit.UK defederated from eviltoast

    My instance seems to have de-federated from it already as well.

    The lemmy.today instance has more local content and engagement, but I can’t seem to interact with its communities from my Mbin account. So I can’t contact their admins and report issues.

    Maybe the mod from Blahaj that removed their content can report the problem to their instance?




  • I’d like to respond to some of the things discussed in this thread, but I don’t want to directly reply to anyone. I just want to share my perspective, not argue.

    Transgender is currently accepted as an umbrella term and includes a variety of identities. What these identities have in common is that they are not cisgender. Disagreements about which identities fall under the trans umbrella are really about the specificity of the label itself. Some people seem to want the umbrella to be split into two distinctly different labels, with one being specifically for trans people who seek medical transition.

    It all comes down to the definition of transgender as an umbrella term. Definitions of terms change, and it’s not unreasonable to think that transgender may change meaning again in the near future. But right now, “not cisgender” is what defines transgender identities, and that includes non-binary people and trans people that don’t seek medical transition.

    As someone medically transitioning by HRT and seeking SRS, my identity is not diminished in any way by acknowledging the validity of other identities. My recent meme explicitly explains my desire for SRS, and there was no push-back. That’s because I was explaining my own transition and not attempting to define other people.

    Not all trans people seek medical transition, and that’s valid. Not all trans people seeking medical transition want both HRT and SRS, and that’s also valid. And what trans people want for themselves can change. It’s important that non-cisgender people be accepted as transgender so they can accept themselves. Big questions about possible medical transition can be decided later.

    Our enemies are the transphobes attacking our freedoms. Let’s be kind to our fellow trans people.

    ❤️