• letmesleep@feddit.de
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    1 year ago

    Half a litre isn’t really much: A glass with your muesli, a yoghurt for dessert, some sprinkles of cheese somewhere and it’s covered. A litre of milk is about 100g of semi-hard cheese (think gouda), so three slices can get you over the target.

    That’s a lot in terms of animal suffering and environmental damage. Cheese is worse for the climate than beef.

    And given how peasants “survived”, well they didn’t do much more than that. There’s a reason humans only regained their normal size recently. We were much healthier in the stone ages than as peasants. Milk really isn’t particularly healthy and that’s one of the reasons it’s mostly a thing in European and a few populations. Half of the world is still lactose intolerant.

    Basically: Milk had its purpose for a few millennia, but now it’s time to ditch it again.

    • barsoap@lemm.ee
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      1 year ago

      I get it you’re vegan. Rest assured that I don’t even buy non-organic milk, if only for the reason that it doesn’t taste good when the cows only eat soy.

      Malik still prefers most people stick with low-fat dairy, as this helps reduce your intake of saturated fat but still offers good amounts of nutrients.

      I’m not even going to start commenting on that. The 50s want their commercial propaganda back.

      Half of the world is still lactose intolerant.

      Half the world is not culturally and partly genetically descendent from a particular pastoral culture in what’s now Ukraine. You can flip the whole thing around and ask why other cultures didn’t spread as hard and fast as Indo-Europeans did (speaking of initial expansion, not modern-day colonial bullshit).

      Also, half a litre is still within what non-lactose tolerant people can tolerate. It’s pushing it, but possible. I mean most Italians are lactose intolerant and they still have their cappuccino. Then, lactose doesn’t even begin to be an issue when it comes to even moderately ripened cheeses. India would completely collapse without milk as their version of vegetarian doesn’t involve eggs.


      If you want to get your B12 from other sources, be my guest. I literally don’t care. If you want to argue against milk consumption for other reasons, also be my guest. All I wanted to do is how “vegetarian substitute for meat” can be interpreted in a European context that’s on a budget. And it didn’t even involve milk because eggs are more bang for the buck nutrition-wise.

      • letmesleep@feddit.de
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        edit-2
        1 year ago

        I’m not vegan, more like vegetarian and flexitarian with dairy. I’m just trying to explain why (obviously in an orderly fashion, revolutions are expensive) milk from out diet would be a good idea. By now it’s fairly clear that the plant based option have more advantages than disadvantages.. Milks isn’t particularly bad, but it*s in the “controversial” category. I.e. the stuff one should only consume if one likes the taste, but not for health reasons.

        Edit: With eggs the calculation is indeed quite different. They’re less of a problem regarding the climate (if you use the water-free portion as a reference) and indeed helpful for protein.

        • barsoap@lemm.ee
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          1 year ago

          is high in saturated fats,

          Argh that again. No, saturated fats are not unhealthy. Trans fats, hardened fats, different issue but the saturated scare was an advertisement technique to push margarine at butter prices flanked by a campaign by the sugar industry demonising fat as a whole. The whole “science” behind it is “fire fighters found near conflagration thus fire departments cause fires” type logic. The actual epidemic of heart disease back then was due to people smoking like chimneys but how could you blame cigarettes doctors said they’re healthy…

          Producing plant-based milks is also easier on the environment than producing cow’s milk, which requires large amounts of water and causes high levels of greenhouse gas emissions

          Is that based on those “tons of rain falls on cow pastures and cows drink and pee and we’re counting all of that as water usage” numbers. Especially almonds have a much worse water problem, methane burps are an issue yes but can also be addressed by better animal feed and natural supplements, up to 90% reductions and it’s not even expensive.