You must log in or # to comment.
I love Existential Comics so much.
Not to be confused with:
Phallusy fallacy: You’re wrong because you’re a d–k.
In both the Wikipedia examples Alice’s argument was wrong though lol
They were unsound, due to the use of fallacy, but that doesn’t mean they were untrue. Ginger might’ve been a cat, and Alice might’ve been English. The truthfulness of the argument has no bearing on the soundness of the argument (and vice versa)
No, Alice’s argument was fallacious. Whether her conclusion was true or false is not clear from her argument.
